Prior to Colton meeting Cassie Colton appeared on Tia Booth’s season of the Bachelorette. It seemed the two had a connection and Tia even going so far as to tell Becca Kaufrin she had feelings for him. However, Colton left a short time later.
The couple however, connected again on BiP. The connection appeared to be strong at first. However, then we began to see that Colton’s heart just wasn’t in it. He eventually left the island to return home. Though some think it may have to do with the fact that he was in the running to be the next Bachelor.
However, now, fans are speculating… NEXT page