Hannah ultimately decided to stayed with Blake. As others on the beach slammed Hannah for not being as “innocent” as she acted, Dylan wondered if she and Blake dated before Paradise.
Meanwhile, Tayshia and Caelynn got a bit of justice when karma reared it head and Blake ran into a rock on the beach and lost a toenail. The ladies laughed as he grimaced through the pain.
We have a feeling this is far from over for Blake, and we can’t wait to watch it unfold!
Bachelor in Paradise airs on ABC Mondays and Tuesdays at 8 p.m. ET.